Development Updated: April 7, 2023

GitHub Copilot Review

Our comprehensive analysis and hands-on experience with GitHub Copilot

4.6
GitHub Copilot

Overview

GitHub Copilot is an AI pair programmer that helps developers write better code faster by suggesting whole lines or blocks of code as they type. Powered by OpenAI's Codex model, it works across multiple languages and integrates with popular IDEs like VS Code, Visual Studio, and JetBrains IDEs.

Visit Official Site
9
Expert Score
8.8
User Score
4.6
Overall Rating

Pros

  • Exceptional code completion capabilities
  • Seamless integration with popular IDEs
  • Supports numerous programming languages
  • Learns from your coding style
  • Significantly increases development speed
  • Handles boilerplate code effectively

Cons

  • Subscription cost may be prohibitive for some
  • Occasionally suggests incorrect or outdated code
  • May not understand complex project architecture
  • Privacy concerns with code being sent to servers
  • Can make developers overly reliant on suggestions

Detailed Review

GitHub Copilot represents one of the most significant advancements in developer productivity tools in recent years. As an AI pair programmer, it fundamentally changes how developers interact with their code editor, offering intelligent code suggestions that can dramatically accelerate development workflows.

At its core, GitHub Copilot is powered by OpenAI's Codex model, which was trained on billions of lines of public code. This extensive training allows Copilot to understand context and intent in a way that previous code completion tools could not approach. The result is a tool that doesn't just offer simple autocompletions but can generate entire functions, implement algorithms, and even create complex code structures based on natural language comments.

The integration experience is seamless across supported environments. In Visual Studio Code, which offers perhaps the most polished implementation, Copilot appears as ghost text that can be accepted with a tab key or ignored by continuing to type. This non-intrusive approach means developers maintain control over their code while benefiting from AI assistance. Similar functionality is available in Visual Studio, JetBrains IDEs, and even Neovim, making Copilot accessible regardless of your preferred development environment.

Copilot's language support is impressively broad. It excels in popular languages like JavaScript, Python, TypeScript, Ruby, and Go, but also offers solid suggestions for languages ranging from C# and Java to Rust and even more specialized languages. The quality of suggestions does vary somewhat by language popularity (with more common languages generally receiving better suggestions), but the overall experience remains valuable across the board.

Where Copilot truly shines is in handling boilerplate code and common patterns. For tasks like setting up API endpoints, implementing standard algorithms, or creating data models, Copilot can save tremendous amounts of time by generating accurate code that would otherwise require tedious typing or copying from documentation. It's particularly effective when provided with clear comments that describe the intended functionality.

However, Copilot is not without limitations. While it's excellent at generating isolated functions or components, it sometimes struggles with understanding broader project architecture or maintaining consistency across a large codebase. Suggestions occasionally contain subtle bugs or security issues, particularly when implementing security-sensitive functionality. This reinforces that Copilot works best as an assistant rather than a replacement for developer expertise and code review.

The pricing model is subscription-based, with individual developers paying $10 per month and business users paying $19 per user per month. While this represents a significant ongoing cost compared to traditional development tools, many users report that the productivity gains easily justify the expense. For professional developers, the time saved can quickly exceed the subscription cost in terms of development efficiency.

Key Use Cases

Rapid Prototyping

Quickly build functional prototypes and MVPs with AI-assisted code generation

Learning New Languages

Get contextual suggestions while learning new programming languages or frameworks

Boilerplate Automation

Automate repetitive coding patterns and boilerplate code generation

Code Documentation

Generate comments and documentation for existing code

Pricing Plans

Plan
Price
Features
Individual
$10/month
  • Full access to GitHub Copilot
  • Works in multiple IDEs
  • Supports all popular programming languages
  • Unlimited code suggestions
Business
$19/user/month
  • All Individual features
  • Organization-wide deployment
  • Admin controls and policy management
  • IP indemnity
  • Enterprise-grade security
Enterprise
Custom
  • All Business features
  • Enterprise support
  • Custom contracts
  • Compliance features
  • Advanced security

Alternatives to GitHub Copilot

Our Verdict

4.6 /5.0

GitHub Copilot stands as a revolutionary tool in the developer's arsenal, fundamentally changing how code is written. Its ability to understand context, generate relevant code, and learn from your coding style makes it an invaluable assistant for developers of all experience levels. While it's not perfect—occasionally suggesting incorrect code or struggling with complex architectures—its benefits in terms of productivity and handling repetitive tasks are substantial. The subscription cost is justified for professional developers and teams who will quickly recoup the investment through increased productivity. However, Copilot works best when viewed as an intelligent assistant rather than a replacement for developer expertise. Developers should maintain a healthy balance, using Copilot to accelerate their work while still applying critical thinking and code review practices. For most developers, particularly those working professionally, GitHub Copilot represents one of the most impactful tools available today, worthy of its place in the modern development workflow.

Ready to try GitHub Copilot?

Experience the power of this AI tool firsthand and see if it meets your needs.

Visit Official Site
Author
Alex Mitchell
AI Tools Specialist

Alex has been reviewing AI tools for over 5 years and has a background in computer science and machine learning.

Share this review:

User Comments

User
Sarah Johnson 3 days ago

As a full-stack developer, GitHub Copilot has completely transformed my workflow. It's especially helpful when working with unfamiliar libraries or frameworks - the suggestions are usually spot-on and save me from constantly checking documentation. Well worth the subscription!

User
Michael Chen 1 week ago

Copilot is great for productivity, but I've noticed it sometimes suggests outdated patterns or approaches. You definitely need to review its suggestions carefully, especially for security-sensitive code. That said, it's still a huge time-saver for boilerplate and routine tasks.

User
Emma Rodriguez 2 weeks ago

This review is spot on about Copilot's strengths and limitations. I've been using it for about 6 months now, and it's particularly helpful when learning new languages. The suggestions give you a starting point that you can then modify and learn from. Just be careful not to become too dependent on it!

Add Your Review